Nifty Fifty’s - Newtown Square Menu

Welcome to Nifty Fifty’s - Newtown Square, a vibrant spot for breakfast and brunch enthusiasts. Located at 3524 W Chester Pike, this eatery is a haven for burger lovers and milkshake aficionados alike. With ample outdoor seating and a dog-friendly atmosphere, it creates a lively yet cozy environment for all.

The menu is diverse, featuring a range of chicken nuggets – from classic to spicy, each served with your choice of dipping sauce. Their Shake of the Month, the gluten-free Irish Potato, is a must-try for any adventurous palate. Don't miss the popular milkshakes, including the decadent Birthday Cake and creamy Oreo Cheesecake, each topped with whipped cream for a touch of indulgence.

Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Nifty Fifty’s promises a memorable culinary experience that bursts with flavor and nostalgia.

30 Nugget Tray

Chicken Nugget Party Trays!Served with 1 dipping sauce of your choice.Chicken Nugget Styles- Original- Buffalo- Cheese- Garlic Parm- Honey BBQ- Spicy- Spicy Cheese- Spicy Thai Chili

$30.59

60 Nugget Tray

Chicken Nugget Party Trays!Served with 2 dipping sauces of your choice.Chicken Nugget Styles- Original- Buffalo- Cheese- Garlic Parm- Honey BBQ- Spicy- Spicy Cheese- Spicy Thai Chili

$55.98

Cheeseburger Tray

Our Signature Party Cheeseburger Tray.Lettuce, fried or raw onions, pickles, relish, tomatoes, ketchup and mustard on the side available upon request.

$55.19

Party Trays

Nifty Burgers

Bacon Cheeseburger

Hand-pattied burger topped with cheese and crispy bacon.

$7.67

Chili Cheeseburger

Hand-pattied cheeseburger topped with our homemade Chili.

$7.38

Royal Burger

Cheeseburger crowned with a homemade onion ring.

$7.38

Hamburger

Freshly ground and hand-pattied burger.

$5.87

Cheeseburger

Hand-pattied burger topped with cheese.

$6.42

Mushroom Swiss Burger

Hand-pattied burger topped with Swiss cheese and Fresh Grilled Mushrooms.

$7.38

Leo Special Burger

Cheeseburger with tomato, onion and relish.

$6.42

Texas Ringer

Our #1 Selling Burger!Topped with cheese, bacon, an onion ring, lettuce and Texas Petal Sauce.

$8.27

Turkey Cheeseburger

4.5 oz fresh ground patty topped with cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomato.(Double Turkey Cheeseburger is served on a kaiser roll.)

$8.75

The "Beyond" Burger

Beyond Meat's Famous plant-based Veggie Burger served on a grilled roll with lettuce and tomato.(Double "Beyond" Burger is served on a kaiser roll.)

$11.39

Cheesesteak

Served with your choice of cheese, served on a long roll.

$14.70

Mushroom Swiss Cheesesteak

Served with mushrooms and Swiss cheese, served on a long roll.

$15.42

Bacon Cheddar Cheesesteak

Served with crispy bacon and cheddar cheese, served on a long roll.

$15.71

Chicken Cheesesteak

Tender, diced chicken served with your choice of cheese, on a long roll.

$14.70

Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak

Buffalo Chicken Steak served with lettuce and American cheese, topped with bleu cheese and grated Parmesan cheese.

$15.54

Mushroom Swiss Chicken Cheesesteak

Tender, diced chicken served with mushrooms and Swiss cheese, served on a long roll.

$15.42

Chicken Caesar Steak

Our #1 Selling Philly Steak!Our famous chicken steak served over a bed of Caesar salad, topped with fresh hand grated Parmesan cheese.

$15.18

Philly Steaks

Specialty Sandwiches

Filet Mignon Sandwich

Top Choice Western Steer Filet served on a grilled kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, and American cheese. Cooked Medium-Well unless otherwise specified.

$17.15

Filet Mignon Special

Top Choice Western Steer Filet served on a grilled kaiser roll with American cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and onion. Cooked Medium-Well unless otherwise specified.

$19.07

Mushroom Filet Mignon Sandwich

Top Choice Western Steer Filet served on a grilled kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, and Swiss cheese and mushrooms. Cooked Medium-Well unless otherwise specified.

$17.94

Royal Filet Mignon

Top Choice Western Steer Filet served on a grilled kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, American cheese and crowned with two homemade onion rings. Cooked Medium-Well unless otherwise specified.

$17.94

Chicken Cutlet

"Hand breaded to order" and topped with whiz and pickles, served on a kaiser roll.

$11.46

Buffalo Chicken Cutlet

With lettuce, bleu cheese and American cheese, served on a kaiser roll.

$11.82

Honey Grilled Chicken

With lettuce and tomato.

$10.67

Honey Grilled Chicken Texas Ringer

Served with cheese, bacon, two onions rings, lettuce and Texas Petal Sauce.

$13.14

Honey Grilled Mushroom Swiss Chicken

With lettuce and tomato.

$12.18

Fish Filet

Freshly breaded and golden fried cod fish, served with lettuce, tomato, tartar sauce and a lemon wedge on a grilled roll.

$11.04

Hot Dog

Old fashioned Boardwalk Style" Hot Dog.(Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)

$5.39

Cheese Hot Dog

Old fashioned Boardwalk Style" Hot Dog with Whiz.(Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)

$6.59

Chili Hot Dog

Old fashioned Boardwalk Style" Hot Dog topped with our homemade chili.(Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)

$6.59

Kraut Hot Dog

Old fashioned Boardwalk Style" Hot Dog topped with sauerkraut.(Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)

$6.59

Chili Cheese Hot Dog

Old fashioned Boardwalk Style" Hot Dog topped with our homemade chili and Whiz.(Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)

$7.19

Texas Tommy

Hot Dog wrapped in bacon with Whiz(Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)

$7.50

Chili Texas Tommy

Hot Dog wrapped in bacon topped with our homemade chili and Whiz(Our Hot Dogs are a blend of pork and beef.)

$9.00

Coney Island Hot Dogs

Chicken Nuggets and Chicken Fingers

Nuggets

Your choice of 6, 9, or 15 chicken nuggets, served with your choice of dipping sauce.

$7.38

Spicy Nuggets

Your choice of 6, 9, or 15 chicken nuggets topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning, served with your choice of dipping sauce.

$8.10

Cheese Nuggets

Your choice of 6, 9, or 15 chicken nuggets topped with Whiz, served with your choice of dipping sauce.

$8.63

Spicy Cheese Nuggets

Your choice of 6, 9, or 15 chicken nuggets topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning and Whiz, served with your choice of dipping sauce.

$9.30

Fingers

Your choice of 2 , 5, or 8 chicken fingers, served with your choice of dipping sauce.

$5.87

Spicy Fingers

Your choice of 2 , 5, or 8 chicken fingers topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning, served with your choice of dipping sauce.

$6.66

Cheese Fingers

Your choice of 2 , 5, or 8 chicken fingers topped with Whiz, served with your choice of dipping sauce.

$7.14

Spicy Cheese Fingers

Your choice of 2 , 5, or 8 chicken fingers topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning and Whiz, served with your choice of dipping sauce.

$7.86

Fries

Fresh-cut fries, made from locally grown potatoes. Available in both regular and large sizes.Gluten Free

$5.70

Spicy Fries

Fresh-cut fries, made from locally grown potatoes, topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning. Available in both regular and large sizes.Gluten Free

$6.30

Cheese Fries

Fresh-cut fries, made from locally grown potatoes, topped with Whiz. Available in both regular and large sizes.Gluten Free

$6.90

Spicy Cheese Fries

Fresh-cut fries, made from locally grown potatoes, topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning and Whiz. Available in both regular and large sizes.Gluten Free

$7.50

Onion Rings

Fresh and hand-breaded sweet onions deep-fried to perfection, served with a side of Texas Petal Sauce.

$7.79

Spicy Onion Rings

Fresh and hand-breaded sweet onions deep-fried to perfection, topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning. Served with a side of Texas Petal Sauce.

$8.39

Cheese Onion Rings

Fresh and hand-breaded sweet onions deep-fried to perfection, topped with Whiz. Served with a side of Texas Petal Sauce.

$9.23

Spicy Cheese Onion Rings

Fresh and hand-breaded sweet onions deep-fried to perfection, topped with our Pistol Pete's Spicy Seasoning and Whiz. Served with a side of Texas Petal Sauce.

$9.95

Fresh Cut Fries and Onion Rings

Gluten Free

$9.30

Coconut

Contains Nuts

$9.30

Coffee

Gluten Free

$9.30

Cotton Candy

Gluten Free

$9.30

Bubble Gum

$9.30

Grape

Gluten Free

$9.30

Green Apple

Gluten Free

$9.30

Key Lime

Gluten Free

$9.30

Lemon

$9.30

Mango

Gluten Free

$9.30

Marshmallow

Gluten Free

$9.30

$10.55

Wholly Cannoli

$10.55

Classic Favorite Exotic Milk Shakes

$10.55

Cheesecake Exotic Milk Shakes

Cookie and Candy Bar Exotic Milk Shakes

Chips Ahoy

$10.55

Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

$10.55

Strawberry Oreo

$10.55

$10.55

Nifty Fifty’s - Newtown Square Menu

Shake Of The Month

Irish Potato

30 Nugget Tray

60 Nugget Tray

Cheeseburger Tray

Party Trays

Nifty Burgers

Bacon Cheeseburger

Chili Cheeseburger

Royal Burger

Hamburger

Cheeseburger

Mushroom Swiss Burger

Leo Special Burger

Texas Ringer

Turkey Cheeseburger

The "Beyond" Burger

Cheesesteak

Mushroom Swiss Cheesesteak

Bacon Cheddar Cheesesteak

Chicken Cheesesteak

Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak

Mushroom Swiss Chicken Cheesesteak

Chicken Caesar Steak

Philly Steaks

Specialty Sandwiches

Filet Mignon Sandwich

Filet Mignon Special

Mushroom Filet Mignon Sandwich

Royal Filet Mignon

Chicken Cutlet

Buffalo Chicken Cutlet

Honey Grilled Chicken

Honey Grilled Chicken Texas Ringer

Honey Grilled Mushroom Swiss Chicken

Fish Filet

Hot Dog

Cheese Hot Dog

Chili Hot Dog

Kraut Hot Dog

Chili Cheese Hot Dog

Texas Tommy

Chili Texas Tommy

Coney Island Hot Dogs

Chicken Nuggets and Chicken Fingers

Nuggets

Spicy Nuggets

Cheese Nuggets

Spicy Cheese Nuggets

Fingers

Spicy Fingers

Cheese Fingers

Spicy Cheese Fingers

Fries

Spicy Fries

Cheese Fries

Spicy Cheese Fries

Onion Rings

Spicy Onion Rings

Cheese Onion Rings

Spicy Cheese Onion Rings

Fresh Cut Fries and Onion Rings

Smothered Fries

Smothered Honey Barbecue Chicken Fries

Smothered Cheezy Bacon Ranch Fries

Smothered Philly Cheesesteak Fries

Smothered Buffalo Chicken Fries

Smothered Chili Cheese Fries

Smothered Crab Meat Fries

Spicy Chicken Ranch Salad

Nifty Caesar Salad

Bowl Chili

Salads & Chili

Waffles

Whole Belgian Waffles

Chicken & Waffles

Birthday Cake

Black and White

Butterscotch Krimpet